Guests are free to browse the forums, although you will need to register for an account if you wish to participate in the discussions or use any of the advanced features of the forum (bookmarks, history, etc).
If you already have an account, please sign in now.
The Watercooler is powered by Vanilla, the sweetest forum on the web.
Whatever you think of the show today, your favorite season is probably Season 2, followed by Season 1. If not, well, you can just get the he-- no, that's not right. But if you agree, then join the Great NA S1/S2 Mid-Season Rewatch.
Details so far
Details to be decided
* Bueller? Bueller?
Well, I'm voting here cause I'm a mod and I can do what I want. So there.
Maybe we could do a S3 rewatch this summer? I know it has its flaws, but it's also pretty good, especially now that we have (or will have) three years of perspective. I definitely have some favorites from that season.
Should we include S3 episodes? I vote no, but that's just one vote. A well-informed and highly influential vote, but still just one vote.
I like the idea of not using S3 episodes.
Shunning in progress.
We could do S3 in the summer. It would give us a lot more things to argue about, I mean, discuss.
Here are my thoughts:
We watch sometime Thurs night. No specific time.
Seasons 1 and 2 only, for now. The one thing about S3 is that it brought us Andy. I enjoy what he brings to the show.
I think we can handle two episodes in one night. Without commercials that is less than 45 minutes. And discussions in two threads is better than one.
Yes, this is not an S3 bashfest. I was just inspired by the vibe that rehashing a couple of S2 episodes generated.
As for two in one night, I'll leave that to everyone else in the circle. (S3 reference, meta-irony!)
No, I didn't mean to diss S3, because I actually liked it.
I was just inspired by the vibe that rehashing a couple of S2 episodes generated.
This.
Also, my top 3 to watch, (even though it was very difficult to pick them, and if you ask me tomorrow, it would probably be different), would be:
The Injury
The Carpet
Christmas Party (because of festive)
Also, I'm okay with using S3 episodes if a lot of people want to.
You wound me, Madge.
I didn't know you weren't a fan of S3, VG. Even though S3 was the season of pain, I think I love it because I watched it on DVD and I didn't have to go through the pain of it in real time like everyone else. I can imagine having to wait a week to find out if something positive was going to happen and then, when it didn't, it must have been awful.
edited to add:
No, I didn't mean to diss S3, because I actually liked it.
I thought so!
Picking my top 3 is going to be rough.
I am always up for a S3 bashfest.
I'm also OK with staying with S1/S2. There are so many we could choose that are great, we don't need to look any farther.
edited to add: I emailed my list.
CZ-J's and VG's votes are tallied. We have an early front-runner. I guess we'll leave the voting open through 12/16, since 12/17 is the first viewing night.
I'll update the first post.
That's funny, because I was just going to post what I had emailed here in order to conform.
Oof, please don't vote both ways. I'm very easily confused. Now VG, did you want pepperoni on that?
Jinx's and gb's votes tallied.
I wrote mine on a piece of burlap with a giant crayon and showed to the camera. Jeff Probst read it aloud.
Jinx's votes are now worth peanuts.
VG's votes will never be tallied, nor should they be because we can't discern her intent.